Sources and interpretations
- A source comes from the time being studied, such as a letter, photograph, cartoon or speech. An interpretation is a later view of the past, such as a historian's book or a documentary.
- Question every source with NOP: its Nature (what kind of source is it?), its Origin (who made it, and when?) and its Purpose (why was it made?).
Judging usefulness
- How useful a source is depends on the question being asked. Even a biased source can be useful, because it shows people's attitudes.
- Judge a source using its content (what it tells you), its provenance (who made it, when and why) and your own knowledge of the context (does it fit with what you know, and what does it leave out?).
Comparing interpretations
- Historians' interpretations differ because of the sources they use, what they focus on, when they were writing, and their purpose or point of view.
- To compare interpretations, identify the difference, support it with details from each, and explain why they might differ.
Exam technique
- Quote briefly, explain what the quotation shows, link it to your own knowledge, and reach a judgement.
- For 'how far do you agree?' questions, argue both sides with evidence, then give a clear, supported conclusion.
- Some answers also earn marks for spelling, punctuation and grammar, so check your writing.
Key terms
- Primary source
- Evidence from the time being studied.
- Secondary source
- A later account of the past, based on other evidence.
- Interpretation
- A later view or explanation of the past, such as a historian's.
- Provenance
- Where a source comes from: who made it, when and why.
- Utility
- How useful a source is for a particular enquiry.
- Bias
- A one-sided view that favours one side.
- Context
- What was happening at the time.
- Corroboration
- Checking a source against other evidence.
- Propaganda
- Information designed to persuade people to think in a certain way.
Quick questions on Source and interpretation skills
- What is a primary source?
- Something from the time being studied: For example, a letter written in 1916.
- What is an interpretation?
- A later view of the past, such as a historian's: It is shaped by the author's evidence and viewpoint.
- What is provenance?
- Who made a source, when and why: It helps you judge how reliable a source is.
- Can a biased source be useful?
- Yes, it can show people's attitudes: Propaganda shows what a government wanted people to think.
- What does 'context' mean when analysing a source?
- What was happening at the time it was made: Use your own knowledge to explain it.
- Why might two historians disagree?
- They used different sources or focused on different things: Their purpose and time of writing matter too.
- What is corroboration?
- Checking a source against other evidence: If other evidence agrees, the source is more reliable.
- What is propaganda?
- Information designed to persuade people to think in a certain way: Governments often use it in wartime.
Source and interpretation skills: questions and answers
- What should you consider when judging a source's usefulness?
- Its content, its provenance and your own knowledge. Always link your judgement to the question.
- What is the purpose of a political cartoon usually?
- To make a point, often by mocking or criticising. Look for exaggeration and symbols.
- Why might a source be less useful?
- It shows only one viewpoint or leaves out key information. Think about what it doesn't tell you.