The question
- Paper 1 Question 4 (20 marks) gives a statement about part of the source, then asks 'To what extent do you agree and/or disagree with this statement?'. It's half of the reading marks on the paper, so spend about 20 minutes.
- Since 2026 the statement doesn't come from 'a student', and you're told which part of the source to use. You could consider your impressions, comment on the writer's methods and support your response with references.
- It tests evaluation: giving your own judgement, and proving it from how the text works.
How to answer
- Decide your view in one sentence before you write. 'Partly' is often the strongest, but you can fully agree if you really argue it.
- Plan three points in 2 minutes, each with one or two short quotations from the named lines.
- Begin each paragraph with your opinion on the statement. Then use the writer's language or structure as your evidence.
- Keep using the statement's own words, and judging words: 'convincingly', 'it's hard to agree that', 'the more telling detail is'.
How it's marked
- Level 4 (16 to 20 marks): a convincing, critical view, with real insight into the methods and well-chosen references.
- Level 3 (11 to 15 marks): a clear, relevant view, with clear comments on the methods and relevant references.
- Level 2 (6 to 10 marks): some attempt to judge, with general comments on ideas and methods.
- Level 1 (1 to 5 marks): simple comments and impressions.
Exam tip
- Write as yourself. 'I think' and 'I'd argue' push you into judging, which is what's being marked.
- Save your strongest idea for last: it's what the examiner reads before deciding on a mark.
Common mistakes
- A language answer with 'I agree' at the top.
- Using the wrong part of the source.
- Making the same point three times.
Key terms
- Evaluate
- To judge how well something is done, and explain why.
- Critical
- Showing careful, thoughtful judgement.
- Interpretation
- A way of understanding a text.
- Writer's methods
- The language and structural choices a writer makes.
- Reader response
- How a text makes the reader think or feel.
- Embedded quotation
- A short quotation built into your own sentence.
In the exam: AQA Paper 1 Question 4: How to answer it, how it’s marked and a model answer with notes
Quick questions on Evaluating a text
- How many marks is Paper 1 Question 4 worth?
- 20: It is the biggest reading question on Paper 1.
- What does 'evaluate' mean?
- Judge how well the writer achieves an effect: Give your view, and explain it.
- How should an answer to Question 4 begin?
- With a clear view on how far you agree with the statement: The examiner should know your view straight away.
- What must you support your ideas with?
- Short, relevant quotations: Short quotations can be embedded in your sentences.
- What do 'the writer's methods' include?
- Language and structural choices: Explain how these methods create the effect.
- Can you disagree with the statement?
- Yes, if you explain your view with evidence: Many good answers partly agree.
- What makes an evaluation 'perceptive'?
- Insightful ideas that consider other interpretations: Show you have thought deeply about the text.
- About how long should you spend on Question 4?
- About 20 minutes: It is worth a quarter of the paper's marks.
Evaluating a text: questions and answers
- Which phrase is evaluative?
- The writer effectively creates tension by… It gives a judgement.
- Should you write about the reader's response?
- Yes, explain how the methods affect the reader. Evaluation is about effects.
- What should you do with the key words in the statement?
- Refer back to them throughout your answer. It keeps your answer focused.