The task
- Paper 2 Question 4 (16 marks) asks you to compare how two writers convey their different feelings and perspectives, using the whole of both sources. Spend about 20 minutes.
- One source is from the 19th century and the other is from the 20th or 21st century.
Viewpoints and perspectives
- A viewpoint is the writer's opinion or attitude, such as being enthusiastic about travel or critical of zoos.
- A perspective is the position the writer is writing from, shaped by their time, age, background, culture and experiences.
Methods to compare
- Tone (for example, formal, humorous, angry or nostalgic), language (emotive words, anecdotes, rhetorical questions, statistics and direct address) and structure (how each text opens and ends, and how it develops the argument).
How to structure it
- Start with a short overview: what does each writer feel, and where are they writing from?
- Then write three paragraphs, with both writers in each: their different views first, then the method that shows each view.
- Example: 'The inspector is confident and formal, whereas the parent has a weary, personal tone…'.
- Comparing words for differences: whereas, however, on the other hand, in contrast, unlike. For similarities: similarly, likewise, both, in the same way.
- Use context in a phrase or two, to explain why the views differ.
Exam tip
- Lead with feelings and ideas. Methods are how you prove them.
- Compare the endings: how a text finishes often shows the writer's final attitude.
Common mistakes
- Writing about one source and then the other.
- Listing a method from each without saying what feeling it conveys.
- A long paragraph of history. Context is a phrase or two.
Key terms
- Viewpoint
- A writer's opinion or attitude on a topic.
- Perspective
- The position a writer writes from, shaped by their time and experiences.
- Tone
- The attitude shown in a writer's voice, such as angry or nostalgic.
- Context
- The time and circumstances in which a text was written.
- Comparative connective
- A linking word that compares, such as 'whereas' or 'similarly'.
- Emotive language
- Words chosen to make the reader feel strong emotions.
- Anecdote
- A short personal story used to make a point.
In the exam: AQA Paper 2 Question 4: How to answer it, how it’s marked and a model answer with notes
Quick questions on Comparing writers' viewpoints
- How many marks is Paper 2 Question 4 worth?
- 16: It is the biggest reading question on Paper 2.
- What is a writer's viewpoint?
- Their opinion or attitude towards a topic: It is what they think.
- What shapes a writer's perspective?
- Their time, background and experiences: A Victorian and a modern writer may see things very differently.
- Which comparative connective shows a difference?
- In contrast: Use it to switch to the other source.
- Which comparative connective shows a similarity?
- Likewise: Both writers share the view.
- What is tone?
- The writer's attitude shown through their voice, such as angry or nostalgic: Word choices create the tone.
- Why should you use context in Question 4?
- It can explain why the writers' perspectives differ: Attitudes change over time.
- What is an anecdote?
- A short personal story used to make a point: It makes an argument feel real and personal.
Comparing writers' viewpoints: questions and answers
- What should each paragraph of your comparison include?
- Points and quotations from both sources. Keep the comparison going throughout.
- Which centuries do the Paper 2 sources come from?
- One from the 19th century and one from the 20th or 21st. This lets you compare perspectives across time.
- What does emotive language do?
- Provokes strong feelings in the reader. It persuades through emotion.