Crime and its causes
- Causes of crime include poverty, upbringing, mental illness, addiction, greed, hate, and opposition to a law thought to be unjust.
- Many religious believers condemn the crime but not the person ('hate the sin, not the sinner'). Some work with prisoners, for example as prison chaplains or through Prison Fellowship.
Aims of punishment
- Retribution (making the offender pay), deterrence (putting people off crime), reformation (helping the offender change), protection (keeping society safe) and reparation (making amends to the victim or community).
Types of punishment
- Prison, community service and fines are used in the UK. Corporal punishment is illegal.
- The death penalty for murder was suspended in Great Britain in 1965 and abolished in 1969.
Forgiveness
- Christians are taught to forgive others as God forgives them, as in the Lord's Prayer; Jesus said to forgive 'seventy times seven' times (Matthew 18:22). Forgiveness doesn't mean there should be no punishment.
- Gee Walker publicly forgave the young men who murdered her son Anthony in 2005.
The death penalty
- Arguments for: retribution ('an eye for an eye', Exodus 21:24), deterrence, and protecting society.
- Arguments against: the sanctity of life, the risk of executing innocent people (such as Timothy Evans, hanged in 1950 and later pardoned), and removing any chance to reform. In 2018, Pope Francis changed Catholic teaching to say the death penalty is 'inadmissible'.
Muslim views on crime and punishment
- Shari'ah is Islamic law, based on the Qur'an and the Sunnah (the example of Muhammad). Muslims believe Allah is just, and that people will be judged on their intentions (niyyah) as well as their actions.
- Many Muslims accept the death penalty for murder, because the Qur'an allows a life to be taken 'by right' (Surah 17:33). But the victim's family may forgive the killer and accept compensation (diyah) instead (Surah 2:178), and some Muslims oppose the death penalty altogether.
- Forgiveness: Allah is merciful and forgiving, and the Qur'an teaches that whoever forgives and makes reconciliation will be rewarded by Allah (Surah 42:40).
- Shari'ah sets out corporal punishments for some crimes, and some Muslim-majority countries use them. Many Muslims believe they should only be used under strict conditions, and others see them as against human rights. Muslims in the UK follow UK law, which doesn't allow corporal punishment.
Key terms
- Crime
- An action that breaks the law.
- Sin
- An action that goes against God's will.
- Retribution
- Punishment that makes the offender pay for their crime.
- Deterrence
- Punishment intended to put people off committing crime.
- Reformation
- Helping an offender change their behaviour.
- Forgiveness
- Letting go of anger and blame towards someone who has done wrong.
- Corporal punishment
- Physical punishment, such as beating.
- Death penalty
- Execution as a punishment for a crime.
- Community service
- Unpaid work in the community as a punishment.
- Shari'ah
- Islamic law, based on the Qur'an and the Sunnah.
- Diyah
- Compensation paid to a victim's family, which Islam allows instead of the death penalty if the family forgives.
Quick questions on Religion, crime and punishment
- What is retribution?
- Punishment that makes the offender pay for their crime: It is sometimes linked to 'an eye for an eye'.
- What is deterrence?
- Punishment that puts people off committing crime: It aims to prevent future crime.
- What is reformation?
- Helping the offender change their behaviour: Education and counselling in prison support it.
- Is corporal punishment legal as a punishment in the UK?
- No, it is illegal: It is seen as cruel and degrading.
- When was the death penalty for murder abolished in Great Britain?
- 1969: It had been suspended in 1965.
- Which teaching do some people use to support the death penalty?
- An eye for an eye: It comes from Exodus 21:24.
- What did Pope Francis teach about the death penalty in 2018?
- It is inadmissible: He changed the Catholic Catechism.
- How many times did Jesus say we should forgive?
- Seventy times seven: It means there should be no limit.
Religion, crime and punishment: questions and answers
- Who publicly forgave the killers of her son Anthony in 2005?
- Gee Walker. She said she forgave them because of her Christian faith.
- What is community service?
- Unpaid work in the community as a punishment. It can help reform offenders.
- What does 'hate the sin, not the sinner' mean?
- Condemn the crime but still care for the person. It encourages treating offenders with dignity.