AQA GCSE English Literature · Paper 1, Section B
AQA English Literature Paper 1: The 19th-century novel
One question on your novel. You’re given an extract, and asked to write about it and about the novel as a whole. There are no accuracy marks here, but clear writing still helps your argument.
- Marks
- 30
- Minutes
- 50
- Tests
- AO1 to AO3
What the question looks like
Starting with this extract, how does Dickens present the change in Scrooge?
Write about: how Dickens presents Scrooge in this extract, and how Dickens presents the change in Scrooge in the novel as a whole.
[30 marks]
How to answer it
Pick out the key word
Underline what the question is about, such as ambition or guilt. Everything you write has to come back to that word, not to the story in general.
Write one big idea
In a line, say what the writer is really saying about it. An idea you could argue with lifts an essay more than any list of techniques.
Plan three or four moments
One from the extract, then two or three from across the novel. For a short book like A Christmas Carol, go through the staves: how does Dickens build the change step by step?
In each paragraph: idea, short quotation, method, why
Build the quotation into your own sentence, zoom in on one word or image, and say what the writer wants the audience or reader to think. Add context where it explains that choice.
How it’s marked
- Level 626 to 30 marks
- A convincing, thoughtful argument. You explore the writer’s methods closely, with well-judged quotations, and link context to your ideas throughout.
- Level 521 to 25 marks
- A thoughtful answer that develops its ideas. You examine how methods work, with apt references, and consider context carefully.
- Level 416 to 20 marks
- A clear answer. You explain the effects of methods with relevant quotations, and show a clear understanding of context.
- Level 311 to 15 marks
- Some explanation, with some relevant references. You name some methods and say a little about their effects, and show some awareness of context.
- Level 26 to 10 marks
- Supported comments that mostly stay at what happens, with some awareness of methods.
- Level 11 to 5 marks
- Simple comments, close to retelling the story.
In our own words. Your teacher can show you AQA’s full mark scheme.
A model paragraph: A Christmas Carol
Here are the lines this answer quotes, so that you can read it against them.
The lines it quotesRead it
For the question: How does Dickens present the change in Scrooge?
Stave 1, when we first meet him: “secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster.”
Stave 5, the morning after the spirits: “I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel, I am as merry as a school-boy.”
The answer
Why it scores
Dickens makes Scrooge’s change feel earned by writing the opening of the story and its ending as mirror images. In Stave 1 he’s ‘solitary as an oyster’, a simile that suggests something shut tight, hard on the outside and closed to everyone. By Stave 5 he’s ‘as light as a feather’ and ‘as merry as a school-boy’, and the rush of similes is itself a release: the sentence can’t contain him any more than his old life can.
An idea about how the book is built (structure), proved with quotations from the start and the end.
Writing in 1843, Dickens needed this change to feel possible for his readers. If a man as far gone as Scrooge can change in one night, then the comfortable Victorian reader has no excuse.
Context as part of the argument: why the writer needed the change to feel this way. Two sentences are enough.
What a weaker answer looks like
At the start Scrooge is mean and at the end he is nice. Dickens describes him as ‘solitary as an oyster’. This shows he is lonely. In Victorian times poor people had a hard life.
Why it stays low: It spots the change and a good quotation, but it doesn’t explore the language, and the context is stuck on rather than explaining anything.
How to lift it: Look at what an oyster is like: hard, shut tight and hiding something. Then say why Dickens needed his Victorian readers to believe that even someone so closed could open up.
Exam tips
- Think about why the writer wrote it: many 19th-century novels argue about how society should be.
- Use the writer’s structure: what’s different between the opening and the ending, and why?
- Say “the reader”, and think about a Victorian reader where it helps.
- Aim for about 15 minutes on the extract and 30 on the rest of the novel, with 5 for planning.
What loses marks
- Treating characters as real people, rather than as the writer’s creations.
- Writing a lot about the writer’s life: it only counts if it explains the text.
- Running out of time because you spent too long on Shakespeare.
- Staying only in the first half of the novel.
Now try it
Revise your text
Questions people ask
- Is there a mark for spelling on this question?
- No. On AQA’s Paper 1, the accuracy marks are on the Shakespeare question. Clear writing still matters, because it makes your argument easier to follow.
- Which is better: Shakespeare first, or the novel first?
- Either is allowed. Do whichever you feel stronger on first, and keep an eye on the clock so that you leave enough time for the other.